goodrecmovies
← back
64.0
Mystery

Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries

Mystery

Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries

2025 – (ongoing) · 1 seasons · 8 episodes · English

Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2025) is a solid-tier series on goodrecmovies, rated 7.7/10 on IMDb from 208 votes. Updated

64.0GRM score
★ 7.7IMDb · 208

After a breakup, Cheryl takes over an Amish gift shop in Sugarcreek. Strange stuffed animals, a kidnapping, and hidden feuds force her, Naomi, and Levi into a thrilling search.

Where to watch

JustWatch
UP Faith & Family Apple TV channelUP Faith & Family Amazon Channel

Top cast

12
Galadriel Stineman
Cheryl Cooper
Denise Gossett
Naomi Miller
Kevin Joy
Levi Miller
Riley Beeson
Esther Miller - Young Naomi Miller
Riley Beeson
Esther Miller
Ryan O'Quinn
Seth Miller
Lance E. Nichols
Chief Twitchell
Lance E. Nichols
Officer Twitchell
Lauren Paulis
Elizabeth Miller
Christophe Farrell
Caleb Miller
Candace Kirkpatrick
Aunt Mitzi
Kristen Grace Gonzalez
Officer Ortega

Seasons

1

best episode: S1E6 — Stitch in time ★ 8.3 (24)

S18 eps · ★ 7.7
  • E1The buggy before the horse★ 7.340
  • E2A season of secrets★ 7.430
  • E3Oh little town of Sugarcreek★ 7.828
  • E4Off the Beaten Path★ 7.524
  • E5Simply Vanished★ 7.723
  • E6Stitch in time★ 8.324
  • E7Mason Jar Mayhem★ 7.620
  • E8When there's a will★ 8.219

Tonight's ranking

See all
C
88.7
Chernobyl
2019
H
87.2
Heated Rivalry
2025
S
86.3
Sapne Vs Everyone
2023
D
85.0
Dexter: Resurrection
2025
A
84.7
Attack on Titan
2013
T
84.7
Takopi's Original Sin
2025

More like this

See all
D
85.0
Dexter: Resurrection
2025
A
74.3
A Time Called You
2023
S
72.5
Severance
2022
W
73.7
Watchmen
2019
H
75.0
The Haunting of Hill House
2018
D
79.2
Dark
2017
W
73.5
Westworld
2016
N
73.0
The Night Of
2016
S
72.7
Sense8
2015
L
76.2
The Leftovers
2014
S
76.3
Sherlock
2010
D
73.0
Dexter
2006

Comments

Comments are moderated against a short code of conduct. Disagree as much as you like; do it kindly.

Where to watch

JustWatch

Seasons

1

best episode: S1E6 — Stitch in time ★ 8.3 (24)

S18 eps · ★ 7.7
  • E1The buggy before the horse★ 7.340
  • E2A season of secrets★ 7.430
  • E3Oh little town of Sugarcreek★ 7.828
  • E4Off the Beaten Path★ 7.524
  • E5Simply Vanished★ 7.723
  • E6Stitch in time★ 8.324
  • E7Mason Jar Mayhem★ 7.620
  • E8When there's a will★ 8.219

Top cast

12
GGaladriel StinemanCheryl CooperDDenise GossettNaomi MillerKKevin JoyLevi MillerRRiley BeesonEsther Miller - Young Naomi MillerRRiley BeesonEsther MillerRRyan O'QuinnSeth MillerLLance E. NicholsChief TwitchellLLance E. NicholsOfficer TwitchellLLauren PaulisElizabeth MillerCChristophe FarrellCaleb MillerCCandace KirkpatrickAunt MitziKKristen Grace GonzalezOfficer Ortega

More like this

See all
D85.0Dexter: Resurrection2025A74.3A Time Called You2023S72.5Severance2022W73.7Watchmen2019H75.0The Haunting of Hill House2018D79.2Dark2017W73.5Westworld2016N73.0The Night Of2016S72.7Sense82015L76.2The Leftovers2014S76.3Sherlock2010D73.0Dexter2006

Comments

Comments are moderated against a short code of conduct. Disagree as much as you like; do it kindly.